CARVANA LLC, DOT #2386128 FMCSA Safety & Compliance Report

GREENFIELD, Indiana · DOT #2386128 · 2458 trucks · 1720 drivers · Safety Rating: Satisfactory

Over 100 trucks: Scoped with the FileFlo compliance team and priced in writing.

Talk to us →

1 of your 50 roadside inspections in the last 24 months ended with an out-of-service order, most recently Michigan on November 12.

Your latest, Massachusetts on November 17, had 3 violations, none out of service.

Your MCS-150 lists 2458 trucks and 1720 drivers.

Every violation on this list stays on your FMCSA record for 24 months and counts toward the scores FMCSA uses to choose carriers for an investigation. The investigator asks for the files behind each one.

CARVANA LLC is a large fleet motor carrier based in GREENFIELD, Indiana (USDOT #2386128). As of November 19, 2026, it holds a Satisfactory FMCSA safety rating and a FileFlo Carrier Intelligence Score of 59/100 (Elevated Risk), based on 50 recent inspection(s) and 17 recorded violation(s) in public FMCSA data.

What CARVANA LLC's record points to

Free FMCSA Audit · 60 seconds · No signup

Run a CFR-cited gap audit on CARVANA LLC

Pulls the same Socrata data shown above. Grades against the rule pack FileFlo runs internally. Every gap names its 49 CFR section.

Run free audit →

I wrote The FMCSA Audit Survival Guide.

Take the book. Free.

238 pages on the paperwork side of trucking. Every checklist in it, yours.

The complete digital edition · Every checklist and template · Unsubscribe anytime

Free FMCSA record alerts

Is this your company? Get free alerts when this record changes.

FileFlo emails you the morning the public FMCSA record for CARVANA LLC shows a new roadside inspection, an insurance cancellation or suspension notice, an authority change, the MCS-150 update coming due, or a safety rating change. Free, and FileFlo is not the DOT.

Turn on free alerts

Carrier Intelligence Score

59/100 Elevated Risk

CategoryScoreMax
Safety Rating3030
Inspection Pass Rate2020
Out-of-Service Rate (vs FMCSA national avg)1515
CSA BASIC percentilesNot measuredn/a

Three public FMCSA components, scored by FileFlo. CSA BASIC percentiles are not in FMCSA's public data, so they are shown as not measured.

CARVANA LLC's public FMCSA record, line by line

Roadside inspections in the last 24 months

  • Nov. 17, 2026, Massachusetts. 3 violations, none out of service. Written up for a state or local traffic violation (49 CFR 392.2), company name or USDOT number not shown on the truck (49 CFR 390.21), and wipers not working (49 CFR 393.78).
  • Nov. 16, 2026, Iowa. No violations.
  • Nov. 16, 2026, New York. 1 violation, none out of service. Written up for lights not working (49 CFR 393.9).
  • Nov. 16, 2026, Alabama. No violations.
  • Nov. 16, 2026, Massachusetts. 1 violation, none out of service. Written up for wipers not working (49 CFR 393.78).
  • Nov. 16, 2026, New York. No violations.

Operating authority and insurance

FMCSA's licensing record shows MC819900, operating authority, granted on October 13, 2020.

CARVANA LLC: GREENFIELD, Indiana Trucking Company

CARVANA LLC is a large fleet operating out of GREENFIELD, Indiana with USDOT number 2386128. The company operates 2458 power units and holds a current FMCSA safety rating of Satisfactory. Based on our analysis of federal safety data, CARVANA LLC has a FileFlo Carrier Intelligence Score (CIS) of 59/100, classified as Elevated Risk.

FMCSA Safety Record & Inspection History

CARVANA LLC has undergone 50 recorded DOT inspections. The vehicle out-of-service rate is 2.0%, which is below the national average of 20.72%, suggesting solid vehicle maintenance practices.

Recorded Violations and Out-of-Service Status

The public FMCSA record for CARVANA LLC carries 17 recorded violations, and the most recent inspection on file is dated November 17, 2026. Across 50 recorded inspections, the record carries 0 driver out-of-service violations and 1 vehicle out-of-service violation.

A recorded violation is what an inspector wrote down at the roadside. It is not a penalty, and it is not an amount owed: FMCSA assesses civil penalties only after a compliance review classifies specific cited violations. The step that changes this record is the document behind each line, so the next move is to see which records an investigator would ask for and which of them exist today.

What a 59/100 Carrier Intelligence Score Means

The Carrier Intelligence Score is FileFlo's own summary of three public FMCSA components for CARVANA LLC: the safety rating, the inspection pass rate and the out-of-service rate against the national average. It is not an FMCSA score, and FMCSA does not use it to choose carriers for an investigation. 59 out of 100 falls in FileFlo's Elevated Risk band.

Authority Type, Hazmat Status, and Operating Profile

CARVANA LLC is classified by FMCSA as an interstate carrier.

The carrier holds an Private Property;Authorized For Hire classification, meaning it transports cargo or passengers for compensation under FMCSA operating authority and is subject to MC-number requirements at 49 CFR Part 365.

CARVANA LLC is flagged in FMCSA Census as a hazardous materials carrier (HM indicator: Y). Hazmat carriers are subject to additional regulations under 49 CFR Subchapter C, including HM-126 reporting, HM-232 security planning, and the Hazmat Cargo Tank Annual Inspection requirement (49 CFR 180.407). Hazmat violations carry their own, higher penalty schedule, separate from the general FMCSA schedule.

Operational range per MCS-150 filing: interstate beyond 100 miles (long-haul, 1720 drivers). The 100-mile boundary matters because drivers operating within a 100-air-mile radius qualify for the short-haul exception under 49 CFR 395.1(e)(1), which removes the requirement to maintain RODS for the day.

Self-reported MCS-150 annual mileage: 43,410,487 miles. MCS-150 mileage feeds the FMCSA SafeStat exposure denominator: drastically understated mileage can artificially inflate CSA BASIC percentile scores by reducing the per-mile exposure baseline. Updates are required every 24 months under 49 CFR 390.19.

Fleet Composition and Driver Profile

Owned equipment per the FMCSA Census filing: 2458 straight trucks. Owned-vs-leased equipment matters for compliance documentation, owned trailers require the carrier to retain annual inspection certificates under 49 CFR 396.17, while leased trailers shift that documentation responsibility to the lease agreement.

FMCSA Crash History

The FMCSA Motor Carrier Management Information System (MCMIS) crash dataset records 20 crash events involving CARVANA LLC in the available reporting window. Of these, 0 involved a fatality, 6 involved a reported injury, and 19 resulted in a tow-away. 20 events meet the federal-recordable threshold under 49 CFR 390.5 (fatality, injury treated away from the scene, OR tow-away of any vehicle).

Most recent recorded event: SR 4, THOMPSON (TOWNSHIP OF), OH on November 10, 2026.

CARVANA LLC's Inspection Fingerprint: Geographic Pattern and Trend

Inspections cluster geographically across New York (10), California (9), Maryland (5). The concentration in New York is consistent with the carrier's primary lanes and tends to correlate with which state DOT inspector teams CARVANA LLC's drivers encounter most often at roadside checkpoints.

How CARVANA LLC Compares to the National Average

Across the 50 recorded inspections, CARVANA LLC's 2.0% vehicle out-of-service rate sits well below the FMCSA 2024 national average of 20.72%. The 0.0% driver out-of-service rate sits materially below the 2024 national average of 5.51%.

Have CARVANA LLC's compliance file scoped for a fleet this size

Your last out-of-service was 7 days ago.

The self-serve Audit-Ready Setup covers carriers up to 50 power units. A fleet of 2458 power units is scoped with a person: tell us how USDOT 2386128 is run, how many drivers and files are in scope, and we come back with the scope and the price for that.

Talk to us about CARVANA LLC

Want the gap list first? Run the free FMCSA audit for CARVANA LLC: sixty seconds, no signup, every gap cited to the 49 CFR section. See pricing. Read the founder's FMCSA Audit Survival Guide.

Broker or insurance agent? Partner program

Recent DOT Inspections: CARVANA LLC

Open any inspection for the records an auditor would ask for behind it: free, from USDOT 2386128, no signup.

DateStateDriver OOSVehicle OOSNext step
2026-11-17MA00Audit check
2026-11-16IA00Audit check
2026-11-16NY00Audit check
2026-11-16AL00Audit check
2026-11-16MA00Audit check
2026-11-16NY00Audit check
2026-11-14NC00Audit check
2026-11-14CA00Audit check
2026-11-13IN00Audit check
2026-11-13GA00Audit check

Free · No signup

From the author of The FMCSA Audit Survival Guide. See your carrier's real FMCSA gaps in 60 seconds. Free.

Run a free FMCSA audit on your fleet

Walks every 49 CFR section a new-entrant audit or compliance review actually checks. Every gap names the CFR section that cites it. No signup, no credit card.

Run free audit

Frequently asked questions about CARVANA LLC

What is CARVANA LLC's FMCSA safety rating?

CARVANA LLC (USDOT #2386128) holds a "Satisfactory" FMCSA safety rating. FileFlo's Carrier Intelligence Score for the carrier is 59/100 (Elevated Risk), derived from its safety rating, inspection pass rate, and out-of-service rate versus the FMCSA national average.

How large is CARVANA LLC's fleet?

Per its most recent FMCSA MCS-150 filing, CARVANA LLC operates 2458 power unit(s) and 1720 driver(s), classifying it as a large fleet. Fleet counts are self-reported to FMCSA and can lag a carrier's current operation.

Where is CARVANA LLC based?

CARVANA LLC is registered with the FMCSA at a physical address in GREENFIELD, Indiana, under USDOT number 2386128.

What is CARVANA LLC's DOT inspection and violation history?

FileFlo shows 50 recent DOT inspection(s) and 17 recorded violation(s) for CARVANA LLC (USDOT #2386128), sourced from FMCSA public records and the Socrata transportation datasets. The inspection table on this page lists dates, states, and out-of-service counts.

What is CARVANA LLC's FileFlo Carrier Intelligence Score?

CARVANA LLC scores 59/100 (Elevated Risk) on FileFlo's Carrier Intelligence Score. The score normalizes three public FMCSA components (safety rating, inspection pass rate, and out-of-service rate versus the national average) into one 0-100 surface. CSA SMS BASIC percentiles are not published in FMCSA's public data and are excluded rather than estimated.

Federal rules a carrier like CARVANA LLC is audited against

The 49 CFR sections a DOT compliance review actually checks, plain-English:

Compliance terms: CSA score · out-of-service order · hours of service · driver qualification file. See DOT compliance software & document management →

Every Indiana carrier with a recent inspection on file →

← Browse All Carriers · Indiana Carriers · 2026 FMCSA Penalty Guide · Free FMCSA Audit

Compare the best FMCSA audit prep software →

Data sourced from FMCSA public records and the Socrata transportation dataset. Last updated: November 19, 2026. Information may not reflect the carrier's current status. Dispute this record · Claim this profile

Run free audit on DOT #2386128 →