MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO, DOT #538358 FMCSA Safety & Compliance Report
MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO is a mid-size fleet motor carrier based in SAGINAW, Michigan (USDOT #538358). As of 2026-10-16T06:47:01.917Z, it holds a Not Rated FMCSA safety rating and a FileFlo Carrier Intelligence Score of 74/100 (Moderate Risk), based on 32 recent inspection(s) and 36 recorded violation(s) in public FMCSA data.
Free FMCSA Audit · 60 seconds · No signup
Run a CFR-cited gap audit on MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO
Pulls the same Socrata data shown above. Grades against the rule pack FileFlo runs internally. Every gap names its 49 CFR section.
Take the book. Free.
238 pages on the paperwork side of trucking. Every checklist in it, yours.
The complete digital edition · Every checklist and template · Unsubscribe anytime
Free FMCSA record alerts
Is this your company? Get free alerts when this record changes.
FileFlo emails you the morning the public FMCSA record for MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO shows a new roadside inspection, an insurance cancellation or suspension notice, an authority change, the MCS-150 update coming due, or a safety rating change. Free, and FileFlo is not the DOT.
Turn on free alertsCarrier Intelligence Score
74/100 Moderate Risk
| Category | Score | Max |
|---|---|---|
| Safety Rating | 22 | 30 |
| Inspection Pass Rate | 15 | 20 |
| Out-of-Service Rate (vs FMCSA national avg) | 11 | 15 |
| CSA BASIC percentiles | Not measured | n/a |
CIS subtotal normalizes 3 publicly-available FMCSA components (Safety Rating + Inspection Pass Rate + OOS Rate) to a 0-100 surface. CSA SMS BASIC percentiles are not published in FMCSA's public Socrata datasets and the SMS portal at ai.fmcsa.dot.gov is not crawlable at scale, so we surface a transparent "Not measured" rather than fabricate a score component. Carriers with a Compliance Review on record may have published BASIC data on the SAFER snapshot for that DOT.
MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO: SAGINAW, Michigan Trucking Company
MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO is a mid-size fleet operating out of SAGINAW, Michigan with USDOT number 538358. The company operates 50 power units and has no published FMCSA safety rating (most active carriers are unrated unless they have undergone a compliance review). Based on our analysis of federal safety data, MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO has a FileFlo Carrier Intelligence Score (CIS) of 74/100, classified as Moderate Risk.
FMCSA Safety Record & Inspection History
MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO has undergone 32 recorded DOT inspections. The vehicle out-of-service rate is 6.3%, which is below the national average of 20.72%, suggesting solid vehicle maintenance practices. The driver out-of-service rate is 6.3%, above the national average of 5.51%. Common causes include hours-of-service violations, expired medical certificates, and CDL issues.
Recorded Violations and Out-of-Service Status
The public FMCSA record for MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO carries 36 recorded violations, and the most recent inspection on file is dated 20260923. Across 32 recorded inspections, the record carries 2 driver out-of-service violations and 2 vehicle out-of-service violations.
A recorded violation is what an inspector wrote down at the roadside. It is not a penalty, and it is not an amount owed: FMCSA assesses civil penalties only after a compliance review classifies specific cited violations. The step that changes this record is the document behind each line, so the next move is to see which records an investigator would ask for and which of them exist today.
What a 74/100 Carrier Intelligence Score Means
A CIS score of 74 places MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO in the Moderate Risk category. While not in immediate danger of targeted enforcement, there are areas for improvement. Common issues at this level include inconsistent driver qualification file maintenance, lapsed vehicle inspection schedules, or minor CSA BASIC score creep.
Michigan Trucking Compliance: SAGINAW Area Carriers
Motor carriers operating in Michigan must comply with both federal FMCSA regulations and state-specific transportation requirements. The SAGINAW, MI corridor is monitored by FMCSA field offices and state highway patrol units conducting roadside inspections. Carriers based in SAGINAW should ensure driver qualification files, vehicle inspection reports, and hours-of-service records are current and audit-ready at all times.
MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO falls under the Midwestern Service Center for FMCSA field-office oversight (region code 05). Service-center territory drives which FMCSA Investigator team would conduct a new-entrant audit or compliance review if one is triggered for this carrier.
FileFlo helps Michigan trucking companies automate compliance document tracking across 600+ document types, including CDL medical cards, annual vehicle inspections, drug & alcohol testing records, and driver training certifications.
Authority Type, Hazmat Status, and Operating Profile
MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO is classified by FMCSA as an interstate carrier.
The carrier is classified as Private Property, meaning it transports its own goods incidental to its primary business, exempt from MC-number authority but still subject to safety regulations under 49 CFR Part 390.
Business organization type: Corporation.
MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO is flagged in FMCSA Census as a hazardous materials carrier (HM indicator: Y). Hazmat carriers are subject to additional regulations under 49 CFR Subchapter C, including HM-126 reporting, HM-232 security planning, and the Hazmat Cargo Tank Annual Inspection requirement (49 CFR 180.407). Hazmat violations carry their own, higher penalty schedule, separate from the general FMCSA schedule.
Operational range per MCS-150 filing: interstate within 100 miles (short-haul, 31 drivers). The 100-mile boundary matters because drivers operating within a 100-air-mile radius qualify for the short-haul exception under 49 CFR 395.1(e)(1), which removes the requirement to maintain RODS for the day.
Self-reported MCS-150 annual mileage: 681,378 miles. MCS-150 mileage feeds the FMCSA SafeStat exposure denominator: drastically understated mileage can artificially inflate CSA BASIC percentile scores by reducing the per-mile exposure baseline. Updates are required every 24 months under 49 CFR 390.19.
Fleet Composition and Driver Profile
Owned equipment per the FMCSA Census filing: 33 straight trucks, 17 tractors, 41 trailers. Owned-vs-leased equipment matters for compliance documentation, owned trailers require the carrier to retain annual inspection certificates under 49 CFR 396.17, while leased trailers shift that documentation responsibility to the lease agreement.
The carrier reports 24 CDL-holding drivers on file. Each CDL driver must have a current Driver Qualification File (DQF) maintained per 49 CFR 391.51, including a Medical Examiner's Certificate, an annual MVR review, and a record of road-test results.
FMCSA Crash History
The FMCSA Motor Carrier Management Information System (MCMIS) crash dataset records 8 crash events involving MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO in the available reporting window. Of these, 0 involved a fatality, 2 involved a reported injury, and 7 resulted in a tow-away. 8 events meet the federal-recordable threshold under 49 CFR 390.5 (fatality, injury treated away from the scene, OR tow-away of any vehicle).
Federal-recordable crashes feed the Crash Indicator BASIC in CSA: carriers above the intervention threshold are 7-10x more likely to be selected for a compliance review than peer carriers below the threshold. Insurance carriers also pull federal-recordable crash counts during quoting; a single recordable crash in a 24-month look-back can drive a 10-20% premium increase for owner-operators and small fleets.
Most recent recorded event: STOCKBRIDGE, STOCKBRIDGE TWP, MI on 20241007.
MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO's Inspection Fingerprint: Geographic Pattern and Trend
Inspections cluster geographically across Michigan (31), Indiana (1). The concentration in Michigan is consistent with the carrier's primary lanes and tends to correlate with which state DOT inspector teams MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO's drivers encounter most often at roadside checkpoints.
How MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO Compares to the National Average
Across the 32 recorded inspections, MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO's 6.3% vehicle out-of-service rate sits well below the FMCSA 2024 national average of 20.72%. The 6.3% driver out-of-service rate sits moderately above the 2024 national average of 5.51%. Vehicle OOS-rate variance is the strongest predictor of Vehicle Maintenance BASIC scores in CSA; driver OOS-rate variance is the strongest predictor of Hours-of-Service Compliance + Driver Fitness BASIC scores.
FMCSA's intervention thresholds (the percentile bands that trigger investigator outreach) are roughly 65th percentile for non-passenger non-hazmat carriers (75th for hazmat, 70th for passenger) on each BASIC. Carriers that consistently sit above the national average across multiple BASICs accumulate intervention risk faster than carriers with mixed performance. A single high BASIC alone rarely triggers enforcement; sustained over-threshold performance does.
Have MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO's compliance file built for you
The compliance department you never had to hire.
Every driver's file built and kept current, every expiration and renewal date in front of you before it lapses, and the audit packet ready on demand. For 5 trucks or 50.
The Audit-Ready Setup is $499, one time. Send your paperwork and USDOT 538358; FileFlo files every record against the 49 CFR section that requires it, assembles a driver qualification file per driver, builds the vehicle files, and delivers a gap list with the automatic-failure items first plus your audit packet indexed to the CFR. Your 14 calendar days start once we have your USDOT number, the name of at least one driver and one usable record, and they never pause. If your files are not organized and audit-retrievable by the end of them, the $499 comes back. Your first 30 days of FileFlo are included, and nothing bills automatically after that.
- A full gap report inside 24 hours, with the regulation behind every line
- Driver qualification files, vehicle files, and the audit packet in FMCSA review format
- The Radar on USDOT 538358: one email the day the public record changes
- The guarantee above, printed word for word on the price card
Start the Audit-Ready Setup for MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO →
FileFlo
FileFloQuestions: sales@getfileflo.com
See the work: a sample audit packet · how FileFlo handles your data
Want the gap list first? Run the free FMCSA audit for MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO: sixty seconds, no signup, every gap cited to the 49 CFR section. Or get your free readiness score. See pricing. Read the founder's FMCSA Audit Survival Guide.
Broker or insurance agent? Partner program
Recent DOT Inspections: MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO
Open any inspection for the records an auditor would ask for behind it: free, from USDOT 538358, no signup.
| Date | State | Driver OOS | Vehicle OOS | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | MI | 0 | 0 | Audit check |
| 2026-06-11 | IN | 0 | 0 | Audit check |
| 2026-06-10 | MI | 0 | 0 | Audit check |
| 2026-05-26 | MI | 0 | 0 | Audit check |
| 2026-05-21 | MI | 0 | 0 | Audit check |
| 2026-05-15 | MI | 0 | 0 | Audit check |
| 2025-12-11 | MI | 1 | 0 | Audit check |
| 2025-11-13 | MI | 0 | 0 | Audit check |
| 2025-11-13 | MI | 0 | 0 | Audit check |
| 2025-11-04 | MI | 0 | 0 | Audit check |
Free · No signup
Run a free FMCSA audit on your fleet
Walks every 49 CFR section a new-entrant audit or compliance review actually checks. Every gap names the CFR section that cites it. No signup, no credit card.
Frequently asked questions about MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO
What is MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO's FMCSA safety rating?
MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO (USDOT #538358) does not currently carry a published FMCSA safety rating. A "Not Rated" status is common for carriers that have never had a compliance review: it is not a negative finding. FileFlo scores the carrier at 74/100 (Moderate Risk) from the public inspection and out-of-service data that is available.
How large is MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO's fleet?
Per its most recent FMCSA MCS-150 filing, MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO operates 50 power unit(s) and 31 driver(s), classifying it as a mid-size fleet. Fleet counts are self-reported to FMCSA and can lag a carrier's current operation.
Where is MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO based?
MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO is registered with the FMCSA at a physical address in SAGINAW, Michigan, under USDOT number 538358.
What is MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO's DOT inspection and violation history?
FileFlo shows 32 recent DOT inspection(s) and 36 recorded violation(s) for MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO (USDOT #538358), sourced from FMCSA public records and the Socrata transportation datasets. The inspection table on this page lists dates, states, and out-of-service counts.
What is MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO's FileFlo Carrier Intelligence Score?
MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO scores 74/100 (Moderate Risk) on FileFlo's Carrier Intelligence Score. The score normalizes three public FMCSA components (safety rating, inspection pass rate, and out-of-service rate versus the national average) into one 0-100 surface. CSA SMS BASIC percentiles are not published in FMCSA's public data and are excluded rather than estimated.
Federal rules a carrier like MCNALLY-NIMERGOOD CO is audited against
The 49 CFR sections a DOT compliance review actually checks, plain-English:
- 49 CFR 395.8, Hours of service & ELD records
- 49 CFR 391.51, Driver qualification files (DQF)
- 49 CFR 396.3, Vehicle inspection, repair & maintenance
- 49 CFR 382.301, Pre-employment drug & alcohol testing
Compliance terms: CSA score · out-of-service order · hours of service · driver qualification file. See DOT compliance software & document management →
More Michigan carriers on file
- RAY CONSTRUCTION CO INC, JACKSON (USDOT 538376)
- D & K SERVICE LLC, WARREN (USDOT 538539)
- ACME PALLET INC, HOLLAND (USDOT 538628)
- T & M TRANSPORT INC, REESE (USDOT 539473)
- VANSLOTEN ENTERPRISES INC, SAULT SAINTE MARIE (USDOT 540375)
- ROWLEY BROTHERS INC, BAY CITY (USDOT 540382)
← Browse All Carriers · Michigan Carriers · 2026 FMCSA Penalty Guide · Free FMCSA Audit
Compare the best FMCSA audit prep software →
Data sourced from FMCSA public records and the Socrata transportation dataset. Last updated: 2026-10-16T06:47:01.917Z. Information may not reflect the carrier's current status. Dispute this record · Claim this profile