FileFlo vs. CareSmartz360:
Scheduling Runs the Shift.
FileFlo Runs the Evidence.
CareSmartz360 runs your scheduling, EVV, billing, and caregiver mobile app for private-duty and non-medical home care. FileFlo runs the 42 CFR §441.301, 29 CFR §552.6, and state-licensure evidence binder. Here is an honest side-by-side.
I get this question almost every week from private-duty home care owners: "We already have CareSmartz360. Why would we also need FileFlo?" The short answer is that CareSmartz360 is one of the most-adopted scheduling, EVV, and billing platforms for non-medical home care and Medicaid HCBS waiver agencies. FileFlo is a compliance document platform — both are required to survive a state licensure inspection, a Medicaid HCBS audit under 42 CFR §441.301, or a Department of Labor wage-and-hour investigation of the FLSA companionship exemption under 29 CFR §552.6 — but they cover different evidence categories. CareSmartz360 holds the EVV visit verification, the payor claim, and the caregiver schedule. FileFlo holds the operational, training, wage-hour, and policy evidence trail required by 45 CFR Part 164 and each state's private-duty licensure rules.
This page is not a takedown. CareSmartz360 is one of the leading non-medical home care scheduling and EVV platforms — private-duty agencies in Texas, California, Florida, Arizona, North Carolina, and dozens of other states use it to run Medicaid HCBS and private-pay companion care visits at scale. If you are evaluating FileFlo and CareSmartz360 head to head, you almost certainly need both. The comparison below is honest about where each system wins, where they overlap, and where FileFlo is the only one of the two that does the job.
Quick Verdict
- State licensure inspection + Medicaid HCBS survey binders
- 29 CFR §552.6 FLSA companionship-exemption documentation
- 42 CFR §441.301 HCBS evidence + exception-report packet
- Cross-platform document storage (you keep CareSmartz360)
- 45 CFR Part 164 HIPAA audit trail on every document access
- Flat $299/mo unlimited users — no per-user inflation
- EVV under the 21st Century Cures Act (§441.301)
- State Medicaid aggregator integration in 20+ states
- Direct managed-care organization (MCO) billing
- Caregiver mobile app for visit clock-in / clock-out
- Shift scheduling + auto-fill + cancellation workflows
- Day-of operations for private-duty non-medical agencies
The honest answer for most private-duty non-medical agencies: keep CareSmartz360 for scheduling and EVV, add FileFlo for compliance evidence.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
Based on publicly available CareSmartz360 sales pages, customer reports, and FileFlo product as of May 2026.
| Feature | FileFlo$299/mo · unlimited users | CareSmartz360~$8/user/mo + EVV + modules |
|---|---|---|
| 42 CFR §441.301 HCBS waiver evidence binder | Person-centered plan + exception packet | EVV claims, not evidence map |
| EVV (21st Century Cures Act, §441.301) | Stores EVV exception reports only | State aggregator + caregiver EVV |
| 29 CFR §552.6 FLSA companionship-exemption files | Duty log + 20% household-task evidence | Schedules shifts, not wage-hour proof |
| Medicaid HCBS billing & MCO claims | Not a billing platform | Direct MCO + state Medicaid links |
| Caregiver training & competency tracking | Cert renewals + in-service rosters | Training module add-on |
| State licensure file (per-state private-duty rules) | Per-state binder + renewal calendar | Not built around licensure tracking |
| 45 CFR Part 164 HIPAA audit trail per document | Every view, download, edit logged | EVV + chart-level audit log |
| AI document classification | 600+ doc types auto-tagged | Manual upload & filing |
| Background check & caregiver credential tracking | Per-state renewal automation | HR module add-on |
| Multi-platform document storage | Lives alongside any EVV platform | CareSmartz360 ecosystem-bound |
| State survey plan-of-correction workflow | CAP tracking + evidence upload | Not native to scheduling/EVV platform |
| Caregiver mobile clock-in / clock-out | Not a workforce app | Native caregiver mobile EVV app |
| Pricing model | $299/mo flat, unlimited users | ~$8/user/mo + EVV + module add-ons |
| Free trial (no sales call) | 5-day full access, no card | Demo + sales call + module config |
| Setup time | Under 60 minutes, self-serve | Multi-week module + EVV onboarding |
CareSmartz360 pricing varies by module mix and EVV state contract. Verify directly with CareSmartz360 for an exact quote — pricing range cited from public sources and customer reports.
Where Each Tool Sits Inside §441.301, §552.6, and Part 164
The HCBS waiver rule, the FLSA companionship exemption, and the HIPAA Security Rule map cleanly onto the right system. Here is who handles what.
42 CFR §441.301 — HCBS waivers & the 21st Century Cures EVV mandate
CareSmartz360 wins here cleanly — EVV is what CareSmartz360 does at scale for private-duty non-medical Medicaid HCBS agencies. The §441.301 person-centered service plan, the visit verification, the six required EVV data points (who, what, where, when start, when end, recipient), and the state Medicaid aggregator transmission all live inside CareSmartz360. FileFlo accepts the resulting exception reports, person-centered plan attachments, and missed-visit logs for the evidence binder, but does not generate EVV claims.
29 CFR §552.6 — FLSA companionship-services exemption
This is the wage-and-hour regulation that catches the most non-medical private-duty agencies during a Department of Labor audit. §552.6 limits the companionship exemption to caregivers whose primary duties are fellowship and protection, with no more than 20 percent of total hours per workweek on general household work. FileFlo wins here cleanly — duty logs, exemption-eligibility documentation per caregiver, percentage-of-time evidence, and the third-party-employer overtime acknowledgments live in FileFlo as discrete documents with audit trail. CareSmartz360 schedules the shift but does not produce the wage-hour evidence file a DOL investigator asks for to confirm the exemption.
45 CFR Part 164 — HIPAA Security Rule
Both tools meet 45 CFR Part 164 obligations for PHI handling. The difference is scope: CareSmartz360's audit trail covers EVV pings, visit notes, and payor claim events; FileFlo's audit trail covers every document access, download, edit, and binder export — including the non-PHI compliance docs (training records, policies, background checks, state licensure renewals) that auditors still want evidence of during a state survey or HIPAA risk review.
42 CFR Part 440 — Medicaid services definitions
Personal care services, home-and-community-based services, and self-directed care under 42 CFR Part 440 are the service categories that drive Medicaid HCBS reimbursement. CareSmartz360 stores the service authorization, the EVV-verified delivery record, and the payor claim against that authorization. FileFlo stores the underlying service definitions, the agency's policy of how each service category is delivered, the caregiver training records aligned to that service category, and the state-specific HCBS waiver attestation packet.
45 CFR §164.308 — HIPAA administrative safeguards
Workforce training documentation, sanctions policies, contingency plans, and business associate agreements live on opposite sides of the same regulation. CareSmartz360 tracks the user-account level access controls and the role-based permission model. FileFlo tracks the workforce training acknowledgment per employee, the signed sanctions policy, the contingency-plan documentation, and the executed BAA with every vendor that touches PHI — the document evidence that an OCR auditor asks for during a HIPAA investigation.
State private-duty / non-medical home care licensure
Most states (Texas HCSSA, Florida HHA, California HCO, Pennsylvania HCA, etc.) require private-duty non-medical agencies to maintain a state-specific licensure file: administrator credentials, governing-body policies, caregiver qualification packets, complaint logs, incident reports, and annual renewal attestations. FileFlo wins here — per-state binder, renewal calendar, and incident-log evidence are native. CareSmartz360 does not maintain a per-state licensure file; that documentation typically lives in HR shared drives today.
Real Pricing Comparison
FileFlo is one flat price. CareSmartz360 is per user per month plus EVV state-aggregator fees and module add-ons. The math depends on caregiver headcount, module mix, and your state's Medicaid contract.
* Pricing range based on public sources, industry directories, and customer reports. Contact CareSmartz360 for exact quote.
The pricing comparison is not apples-to-apples. CareSmartz360 is a full scheduling, EVV, and billing platform; FileFlo is the compliance evidence layer. The right comparison is “CareSmartz360 + FileFlo” vs “CareSmartz360 + spreadsheets + shared drives + paper binders”.
When to Pick Each
Add FileFlo if you...
- Already run CareSmartz360 but your survey-readiness binder lives in spreadsheets
- Need 29 CFR §552.6 FLSA companionship-exemption evidence per caregiver
- Just failed a state licensure inspection and need a corrective-action workflow
- Run Medicaid HCBS personal care plus private-pay companion care side-by-side
- Want unlimited user seats without per-user license inflation
- Have multiple branches that need unified compliance evidence
- Want AI to auto-classify uploaded documents — no manual filing
Keep / start CareSmartz360 if you...
- Need EVV under the 21st Century Cures Act mandate
- Need state Medicaid aggregator integration
- Need direct managed-care organization billing
- Need a caregiver mobile app for shift clock-in / clock-out
- Want auto-fill shift scheduling and cancellation workflow
- Are launching a Medicaid-funded non-medical home care agency
"We Added FileFlo on Top of CareSmartz360 Because..."
Real workflows private-duty non-medical administrators describe after layering FileFlo onto an existing CareSmartz360 install.
"CareSmartz360 runs our scheduling and our state EVV. Our FLSA companionship-exemption files lived in a shared drive. The DOL Wage and Hour investigator asked for duty logs proving under 20 percent household work across 60 caregivers and I had to dig through years of folders — that is why we added FileFlo."
"We failed our state licensure renewal because of missing in-service training rosters and an outdated infection-control policy. FileFlo gave us a corrective-action workflow with evidence uploads tied to the citation. CareSmartz360 schedules visits — it does not run a state-survey plan-of-correction."
"We run Medicaid HCBS through CareSmartz360 EVV plus a private-pay companion care line. Our compliance evidence was scattered across HR, scheduling, and billing exports. FileFlo gives us one binder per caregiver regardless of payor type or service category."
Frequently Asked Questions
Does FileFlo replace CareSmartz360?
No. CareSmartz360 is a scheduling, EVV, billing, and caregiver-management platform built for private-duty and non-medical home care agencies — companion care, personal care, and Medicaid HCBS waiver work. FileFlo is the compliance document layer that sits alongside CareSmartz360. CareSmartz360 runs your visit schedule, EVV pings, payor invoicing, and caregiver mobile app. FileFlo runs your 42 CFR §441.301 HCBS evidence binder, 29 CFR §552.6 FLSA companionship-exemption documentation, state licensure files, and 45 CFR Part 164 HIPAA audit trail on every document. Most agencies that use both keep CareSmartz360 for the visit operations and use FileFlo as the survey-readiness binder layer for state Medicaid auditors.
How much does CareSmartz360 cost vs FileFlo?
CareSmartz360 is publicly listed at roughly $8 per user per month for the base scheduling package, with EVV, billing, training, and reporting modules tiered as add-ons that push the per-user fee higher. Implementation, state-aggregator EVV fees, and per-state Medicaid certification are typically separate. A 40-caregiver agency at $8 per user per month is around $320 per month for the base scheduling tier, but the realistic total with EVV and billing modules runs well above that — agencies report effective rates of $15–25 per user per month once all add-ons are stacked. FileFlo is a flat $299 per month with unlimited users for the compliance document layer. The comparison is not apples-to-apples — CareSmartz360 is a workforce operations platform with EVV; FileFlo is the compliance evidence binder. Verify CareSmartz360 pricing directly since module mix and EVV state contracts vary; FileFlo pricing is locked at getfileflo.com/pricing.
Will FileFlo cover the FLSA companionship-exemption documentation under 29 CFR §552.6?
Yes — this is one of the biggest gaps non-medical agencies hit during a Department of Labor wage-and-hour audit. The companionship-services exemption under 29 CFR §552.6 requires that fellowship and protection make up the primary work and that household work for the elderly or infirm is limited to no more than 20 percent of total hours per workweek. FileFlo tracks the exemption-eligibility documentation per caregiver, the duty logs, the percentage-of-time-on-household-tasks evidence, and the third-party-employer overtime acknowledgments. CareSmartz360 schedules the shift; FileFlo holds the evidence trail a DOL Wage and Hour investigator asks for to confirm the exemption actually applies. Without that documentation, the exemption is denied and the agency owes back overtime under the FLSA.
Does FileFlo help with EVV under the 21st Century Cures Act and 42 CFR §441.301?
Not directly — EVV is CareSmartz360's territory. The 21st Century Cures Act amended 42 CFR §441.301 to require Medicaid-funded personal care services to capture six EVV data points: who provided service, what service, where, when start, when end, and the recipient. CareSmartz360 is an EVV vendor that integrates with state Medicaid aggregators in dozens of states. FileFlo does not generate EVV claims. What FileFlo does is store the EVV exception reports, manual entry justifications, missed-visit logs, person-centered service plans, and the compliance evidence packet a state Medicaid auditor asks for when they question your exception rate. That evidence trail typically lives scattered in CareSmartz360 exports and shared drives today — FileFlo turns it into an auditable binder mapped to §441.301.
Can FileFlo generate an audit packet faster than CareSmartz360 for a state licensure or Medicaid survey?
FileFlo is built specifically for survey readiness — one click pulls every document tied to a caregiver, patient, or regulation citation into a single PDF binder with an immutable audit trail under 45 CFR Part 164. CareSmartz360 can export individual reports across scheduling, EVV, training, and HR modules, but assembling a full state licensure plus HCBS §441.301 evidence binder requires running multiple reports and consolidating them manually. Survey-binder assembly is the workflow where FileFlo measurably outperforms a scheduling-and-EVV platform like CareSmartz360 — because document-as-evidence is FileFlo's whole job and CareSmartz360's job is running today's visits.
Does FileFlo integrate with CareSmartz360 for EVV exception data and caregiver records?
Today, FileFlo does not write EVV claims, payor invoices, or caregiver schedules — those stay in CareSmartz360. FileFlo accepts uploaded EVV exception reports, caregiver onboarding packets, training certificates, supervisor sign-offs, background checks, TB screenings, and policy acknowledgments, then AI-classifies them, attaches an immutable audit trail, and alerts on expiration or missing-signature events. A native two-way CareSmartz360 sync is on the FileFlo Q4 2026 roadmap, prioritized because of customer overlap in the non-medical private-duty market. Until then, the integration pattern is: export from CareSmartz360 → upload to FileFlo → AI classify → audit-ready binder under 42 CFR §441.301, 29 CFR §552.6, and state licensure rules.
Authored by Chad Griffith, Founder of FileFlo. Last reviewed 2026-05-29. References: 42 CFR §441.301, 29 CFR §552.6, 45 CFR Part 164, 42 CFR Part 440.
Add the Compliance Layer Your Scheduling Platform Doesn't Cover
5-day free trial. No credit card. No sales call. No module-config paperwork. Build your first 42 CFR §441.301 evidence binder today — keep CareSmartz360 for scheduling and EVV.
$299/mo · Unlimited users · Cancel anytime · No implementation fees